- Form 1 of the European Society for Medical Oncology-Magnitude of Clinical Benefit Scale (ESMO-MCBS) is used to grade therapies with curative intent.
- The study aimed to evaluate the applicability and reasonableness of the ESMO-MCBS scores in early colon cancer.
- Adjuvant studies were sourced from various medical and regulatory databases and guidelines, then graded using ESMO-MCBS V.1.1.
- In stage III colon cancer, certain chemotherapy trials scored high (grade A), while others showed more modest benefits (grades A and B).
- For stage II colon cancer, fluoropyrimidine trials had 'no evaluable benefit', but a recent meta-analysis showed a 5.4% survival advantage (grade A).
- RCTs and a meta-analysis adding oxaliplatin showed no added benefit.
- Challenges included inconsistent toxicity reporting and limited late toxicity results.
- Field testers largely confirmed the scores' reasonableness but noted the inability to credit improved convenience in non-inferiority trials as a shortcoming.
- Overall, ESMO-MCBS V.1.1 provided very reasonable grading for adjuvant colon cancer studies.